🌟 Editor's Note
Welcome to the launch of the Amateur Investor newsletter, with our first issue the Friday Rundown! Hopefully, you enjoy this weeks issue, lost of movements across the markets. Consolidating it all into one email was challenging, but that is the name of the game. Bare with us as we get our bearings and improve our newsletter over time. Thank you for being a subscriber and welcome to The Amateur Investor.
Markets Consolidate After Fed’s Dovish Pivot
September 18 - 25, 2025
📉🗓️ TL;DR
The Federal Reserve delivered its first rate cut in nine months (25 basis points to 4.00-4.25%), triggering initial optimism before markets settled into consolidation mode. Technology led sector gains despite AI valuation concerns, while major indices posted modest weekly declines (S&P 500 -0.7%, Nasdaq -0.6%, Dow -0.4%). Individual movers included massive biotech breakthroughs (uniQure +248% on Huntington's disease therapy results) and earnings disappointments (CarMax -24%). The labor market showed deeper weakness than expected with a 911,000 job revision downward, supporting the Fed's easing stance while creating uncertainty about economic strength.
📊 Market Pulse
Major Indices Show Mixed Consolidation
Markets showed resilience following the Fed's dovish shift but ended the September 18-25 period in consolidation territory. The S&P 500 declined modestly from 6,664 to 6,615 (-0.7% weekly), while the Nasdaq fell from 22,631 to 22,497 (-0.6%) and the Dow dropped from 46,315 to 46,121 (-0.4%).
The Fed's 25 basis point cut to 4.00-4.25% on September 17th initially boosted sentiment but concerns about AI valuations and labor market deterioration gradually weighed on broader indices. Chair Powell characterized the move as "risk management" rather than emergency action, with the dot plot signaling two more cuts expected through year-end.
Treasury Yields Rise Despite Fed Easing
Treasury yields rose counterintuitively despite Fed easing, with the 10-year climbing to 4.19% and the 30-year advancing to 4.747%. The yield curve steepening reflected market concerns about fiscal sustainability and inflation expectations, creating headwinds for both bonds and growth-sensitive equities.
TLDR: Major indices declined modestly (S&P 500 -0.7%, Nasdaq -0.6%, Dow -0.4%) after Fed's 25bp cut as AI concerns and labor market weakness offset initial optimism. Treasury yields rose counterintuitively to 4.19% (10-year).
Sources: CNBC, Federal Reserve, CNN Business, Fortune
🏦 Fed Policy & Economic Data
Employment Data Reveals Deeper Weakness
The central bank's pivot came against a backdrop of concerning employment data that revealed deeper labor market weakness than previously understood. August payrolls added just 22,000 jobs versus 75,000 expected, while a massive benchmark revision subtracted 911,000 positions from the year through March 2025. This data quality crisis at the Bureau of Labor Statistics created additional policy uncertainty and supported the case for continued monetary easing.
The unemployment rate's rise to 4.3% marked a significant deterioration, with Powell noting a "marked slowdown" in labor conditions. Only newly appointed Governor Stephen Miran dissented, favoring a more aggressive 50 basis point reduction. Markets initially priced in 100% probability of the September cut after the employment disappointments, though the more gradual pace ultimately delivered left some investors wanting more aggressive action.
Mixed Economic Signals Complicate Fed’s Path
Mixed economic signals complicated the Fed's path forward. While retail sales surged 0.6% in August above the 0.2% expected, housing starts fell 8.5% and building permits declined 3.7%. The combination of labor market softening and persistent tariff-driven inflation pressures created a challenging environment for monetary policy, with headline CPI running at 2.9% year-over-year.
Housing market data showed continued weakness despite expectations that Fed easing would help mortgage rates. Housing starts fell 8.5% to 1.307 million annualized while building permits declined 3.7% to 1.312 million. Year-over-year building permits were down 11.1%, indicating persistent headwinds for the residential construction sector.
TLDR: Fed cut 25bp citing labor market weakness revealed by massive 911,000 job revision downward. Mixed data with retail sales strong (+0.6%) but housing starts down 8.5%. Unemployment rose to 4.3%.
Sources: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Federal Reserve, CNBC, U.S. Census Bureau
🏭 Sector Specific Performance
Technology Leads Despite AI Reality Check
Technology led sector performance with a 2.42% weekly gain despite experiencing notable volatility around artificial intelligence investments. The sector's 40% surge since April faced scrutiny as investors questioned the sustainability of AI valuations, particularly after Nvidia's announcement of a $100 billion OpenAI investment raised concerns about circular relationships within the AI ecosystem.
Oracle emerged as a standout performer, driven by massive cloud infrastructure contracts totaling $455 billion in remaining performance obligations. The company's AI infrastructure deals supported projections for $144 billion in cloud revenue over four years. However, Nvidia declined 2.8% on September 22 amid broader skepticism about AI trade fundamentals, while semiconductor stocks generally faced "base effect" concerns despite strong underlying demand.
Industrials Deliver Strong Performance
Industrials delivered robust 4.33% weekly performance supported by defense spending increases and infrastructure investments. Germany's $190 billion defense budget and $55 billion in U.S. emerging technology spending provided tailwinds for aerospace and defense companies. The Fed's rate cuts particularly benefited capital-intensive industrial sectors, with the XLI trading at attractive 1.51 PEG ratio versus broader market multiples.
Financial Services Maintain Steady Gains
Financial services maintained steady outperformance with 3% year-to-date gains and the lowest PEG ratio at 1.51 among major sectors. Banks benefited from the rate cut cycle beginning while maintaining net interest margins, supported by strong credit quality improvements.
Healthcare Significantly Underperforms
Healthcare significantly underperformed with only 1.5% YTD returns compared to technology's 40% surge, weighed down by Trump administration threats of 200% pharmaceutical tariffs and leadership uncertainty at UnitedHealth.
TLDR: Technology led with +2.42% weekly gains despite AI valuation concerns. Industrials strong at +4.33% on defense spending. Healthcare lagged with only 1.5% YTD vs tech's 40% surge.
Sources: Morningstar, CNBC, Merrill Lynch, ETF.com
📸 Company Spotlight
Biotech Breakthroughs Drive Massive Gains
BioXcel Therapeutics surged 151.97% after announcing that its SERENITY At-Home Phase 3 trial met primary endpoints for treating agitation in bipolar disorders and schizophrenia. The company's IGALMI treatment showed favorable tolerability across 2,437 agitation episodes with no treatment arm discontinuations, supporting plans for a supplemental FDA filing.
The most dramatic single-day move came from uniQure, which exploded 248% to over $47.50 after releasing pivotal Phase 1/2 results for its Huntington's disease gene therapy. The AMT-130 treatment demonstrated 75% slowing of disease progression at 36 months with statistical significance (p=0.003), prompting Cantor Fitzgerald to raise its price target to $80. The company plans BLA submission in Q1 2026 with potential launch later that year.
Earnings Disappointments Hit Consumer Discretionary
On the downside, CarMax plunged 24% on disappointing Q2 2025 earnings that missed consensus by 38% with EPS of $0.64 versus expected $1.03-1.09. Revenue fell 6% short of estimates at $6.59 billion while same-store sales declined 7.1% year-over-year. The used car retailer's challenges reflected broader consumer discretionary pressures, with higher loan loss provisions hitting CarMax Auto Finance income.
M&A Activity Provides Support
M&A activity provided support for several names, including the completion of SERB Pharmaceuticals' $412 million acquisition of Y-mAbs Therapeutics at $8.60 per share, representing a 105% premium that drove the stock up 103.10% before delisting.
TLDR: Biotech breakthroughs dominated with uniQure +248% (Huntington's therapy) and BioXcel +152% (Phase 3 trial success). CarMax plunged -24% on earnings miss. M&A activity supported Y-mAbs (+103%).
Sources: Yahoo Finance, Benzinga, Stock Titan, Investing.com, GlobeNewswire
💱 Commodities & Currency Watch
Oil Remains Range-Bound Amid Geopolitical Tensions
Commodities showed mixed performance as fundamental factors outweighed monetary policy influences. WTI crude oil traded around $64.75, up 2.11% in recent sessions but remaining range-bound between $61.45-66.03. President Trump's calls for lower oil prices to pressure Russia created downward pressure, while Ukrainian attacks on Russian energy infrastructure provided upside risks.
Gold Pulls Back From Highs
Gold fell to near two-week lows around $3,774 as safe-haven demand diminished following reports of potential Iran-Israel ceasefire discussions. Despite the recent pullback, precious metals maintained strong year-to-date performance with long-term forecasts targeting $3,000+ levels for 2025.
Dollar Weakness Accelerates
The dollar index weakened to 97.55-97.70, marking one-month lows and representing a 10.24% year-to-date decline – the steepest in over three years. EUR/USD strengthened to 1.1656 as the ECB's policy stance near the end of its easing cycle contrasted with the Fed's beginning of cuts. GBP/USD hit six-week highs around 1.37+ levels on expectations that interest rate differentials would narrow.
TLDR: Oil range-bound at $64.75 (+2.11%) amid geopolitical tensions. Gold pulled back to $3,774 on ceasefire hopes. Dollar weakened significantly (-10.24% YTD) as EUR/USD and GBP/USD strengthened.
Sources: Trading Economics, FOREX.com, CNBC, CoinDesk
🌍 International Central Bank Watch
Policy Divergence Becomes More Pronounced
International central bank divergence became more pronounced as the ECB held rates unchanged at its September 11 meeting while the Bank of Japan maintained its 0.50% rate on September 19. This policy divergence supported the dollar's weakness while creating cross-currents in global capital flows.
TLDR: ECB held rates unchanged while BoJ maintained 0.50% rate, creating policy divergence as Fed begins cutting cycle. This supported dollar weakness and cross-currency flows.
Sources: European Central Bank, IG International
🔮 Market Outlook
Competing Forces Shape Near-Term Direction
Markets face competing forces as the Fed's easing cycle begins against a backdrop of elevated valuations and persistent inflation pressures. The S&P 500's 22x forward earnings multiple prompted Fed Chair Powell to note markets appeared "highly valued," while technical indicators showed RSI levels above 70 suggesting near-term overbought conditions.
Policy Evolution Continues to Create Uncertainty
Tariff policy evolution continues to complicate the economic outlook, with copper tariffs raised to 50% and ongoing trade negotiations creating uncertainty across global supply chains. The WTO's downward revision of 2026 global trade growth to 1.8% from 2.5% reflects continued fragmentation costs estimated between $0.6-5.7 trillion.
Sector Rotation Opportunities May Emerge
Sector rotation opportunities may emerge as rate cuts progress, with healthcare presenting potential value after significantly underperforming technology. The $7 trillion sitting in money market funds represents significant reallocation potential as yields decline, while credit markets remain attractive with tight spreads and higher absolute yields supporting gradual rotation from cash.
The convergence of Fed easing, labor market concerns, AI valuation questions, and ongoing geopolitical tensions creates a complex environment where stock-specific catalysts may drive performance more than broad market moves, favoring active management over passive strategies in the near term.
TLDR: Markets face competing forces with elevated valuations (S&P 500 22x forward PE), ongoing tariff uncertainties, and $7 trillion in money market funds ready for reallocation. Stock selection may matter more than broad exposure.
Sources: World Economic Forum, UPS, BlackRock, Charles Schwab
💡Key Takeaways
The Fed's dovish pivot has begun, but markets are grappling with mixed economic signals, elevated valuations, and sector-specific challenges. Individual stock selection and tactical positioning may matter more than broad market exposure in this environment.
Till next time,