🌟 Editor's Note
Welcome to this weeks issue of The Amateur Investor, we have undergone a massive revision with changes to the style, formatting, delivery, and content of the newsletter itself. We will now be posting once a week and will provide our assessment of the markets grounded by data and fundamentals. We will be starting this transition with our analysis highlighting the absurdity that is currently happening in the markets. As the old adage goes, “history tends to repeat itself” and the stock market is no exception. It is quite clear to us and smart money that we have entered bubble territory and repositioning is necessary before the pop. Keep on reading for our full assessment and additional insights to park your money like Warren Buffett himself. As always, thank you for being a subscriber to The Amateur Investor.

The Fed Put Casino: When 32,000 Lost Jobs Became Rocket Fuel for Record Highs

October 6, 2025

📉🗓️ TL;DR

Markets hit records because the economy is failing, guaranteeing Fed intervention. This "bad news = good news" perversion can't last. Smart money (defense stocks +42-62%, gold at records, Berkshire's $350B cash) is building bunkers while retail celebrates. We're in 1999-2000 redux with AI replacing internet. When breadth breaks below 40% and credit spreads blow past 3%, the music stops. You've been warned.

The Setup

Markets hit all-time highs last week. The S&P 500 closed at 6,716—up 17% year-over-year—while the Nasdaq reached 22,780. The Dow posted its first record of 2025 at 46,758. Financial media celebrated with their usual breathless coverage: "resilient economy," "soft landing achieved," "AI revolution continues."

Here's what actually happened: Private sector employment contracted by 32,000 jobs—the worst monthly performance since March 2023. Consumer confidence collapsed to 94.2, with expectations at 73.4, below the recession-warning threshold of 80 for the eighth consecutive month. Manufacturing contracted for the seventh straight month. The government shut down on October 1, eliminating all economic data just as the Federal Reserve prepares for its October 29 rate decision.

And markets celebrated. Not despite these disasters—because of them.

The VIX sits at 16.65, below its long-term average. Credit spreads compressed to 2.8%, near all-time lows. Put-call ratios show minimal hedging. By every standard measure, markets price near-perfect outcomes ahead.

Except one group isn't buying it. Defense stocks surged 42-62% year-to-date. Gold hit its 36th record of 2025 at $3,887. Bitcoin rallied to $122,000. Berkshire Hathaway's cash position reached $350 billion—55% of total assets. Smart money is building bunkers while retail celebrates at the casino.

The Disconnect

Here's the insanity nobody wants to acknowledge: Markets now rise specifically because the economy is failing.

On Wednesday, October 2, ADP reported 32,000 private sector jobs lost. Markets initially fell, then reversed to close higher. Why? Because terrible jobs data guarantees Fed rate cuts. The CME FedWatch tool immediately priced 97% probability of an October cut, up from 85% the prior week.

Think about that logic: Companies firing workers is bullish because it forces the Fed to print money.

This isn't isolated. August's jobs report showed losses of 3,000 (revised from +54,000 initially reported). Small businesses—the backbone of American employment—shed 40,000 jobs in September. Only mega-corporations with 500+ employees added any positions (+33,000), yet even they announced massive layoffs: Oracle, Intel (5,000+ US workers), Microsoft (9,000).

Year-to-date layoff announcements reached 946,426—the fifth-highest in the 36-year history of tracking. That exceeds totals from the pandemic, Great Recession, and early 2000s recession years. These cuts happened BEFORE any official recession began.

Forward-looking indicators scream disaster. Companies announced just 117,313 new jobs in September—71% fewer than last year. Year-to-date hiring plans total 204,939, comparable to the 169,385 announced during 2009's financial crisis depths. Retail holiday hiring collapsed 75%. Target, Macy's, and Walmart aren't even announcing numbers—unprecedented silence.

Yet markets hit records. The Shiller CAPE ratio reached 40—a level exceeded only twice in 144 years: 1929 before the Great Depression and 2000 before the 78% Nasdaq crash. At CAPE 40, historical models suggest 2.3% total returns over the next decade. Markets would need to fall 62% just to reach average valuations.

The government shutdown amplifies the absurdity. We're flying blind—no jobs reports, no inflation data, no economic indicators. The Fed must make critical rate decisions using private data that shows employment collapsing. Boston Fed President Susan Collins admitted the Fed is "flying blind." Yet markets treat this as bullish because it increases odds of aggressive cuts.

Consumer financial stress reached crisis levels while markets partied. Credit card debt hit $1.209 trillion—30% above pre-pandemic records—with average APR at 22.25%. Delinquency rates reached 3.05%, roughly 125 basis points above 2023 levels. Over 10% of cardholders make only minimum payments—highest in 12 years.

Auto loan delinquencies exceeded Great Recession peaks. The 60+ day serious delinquency rate hit 1.38%, above 2009's 1.33% peak. Subprime auto delinquencies reached 6.6%—the highest since tracking began in 1994. We saw 1.73 million vehicle repossessions in 2024, the most since 2009.

Student loan delinquencies exploded to 10.2% after the payment pause ended. Nearly one in four borrowers with payments due are behind. Seven states show conditional delinquency rates above 30%, with Mississippi at 44.6%.

Personal bankruptcies surged 13.1% year-over-year to 529,080 filings. The savings rate collapsed to 4.6%—40% below pre-pandemic averages. Consumers have no cushion for the unemployment wave building.

Meanwhile, Plug Power jumped 60% in a week. Lithium Americas surged 32%. Bloom Energy soared 28%, trading 201% above fair value. Speculative garbage with no earnings rocketed higher on hope and momentum. The market doesn't care about fundamentals—only that the Fed will keep the music playing.

The Pattern

We've seen this movie before. Specifically, 1999-2000, when markets ignored economic reality until they couldn't.

March 1999: Sun Microsystems CEO declared the "first inning of internet revolution." Cisco spent billions on infrastructure for "unlimited bandwidth demand." Tech companies collectively spent $450 billion (inflation-adjusted) on internet infrastructure. Actual e-commerce revenue: $28 billion. The math didn't work, but stocks soared on "potential."

The parallels to today's AI bubble are exact. Microsoft, Google, and Meta spent $380 billion on AI infrastructure since 2023. Their combined AI revenue? $12 billion. That's a 3% return on investment. While CEOs promise AI will "revolutionize productivity," US productivity growth went NEGATIVE (-0.3% Q3)—first time outside recession.

These companies cut 280,000 workers since announcing AI initiatives. If AI makes workers productive, why fire everyone? Because AI isn't augmenting workers—it's replacing them. Replaced workers don't buy products. Consumer spending drives 70% of GDP. The math fails again.

In 1999, the yield curve inverted and stayed inverted for months. Markets ignored it. Consumer confidence fell. Markets rallied. The Fed raised rates to cool speculation. Markets interpreted it as "soft landing achieved."

By December 1999, CAPE reached 44—the highest ever recorded. Barron's published "Not a Bear Among Them" near the peak, describing universal bullishness. Buffett closed his partnership, stating he didn't understand the market. Sophisticated investors exited while retail poured in.

The pattern always repeats:

  1. Revolutionary technology appears (internet/AI)

  2. Massive infrastructure spending on future promises

  3. Revenue fails to materialize but stocks soar

  4. Fed enables speculation through loose policy

  5. Valuations reach absurd levels as reality disconnects

  6. Smart money exits while retail celebrates

  7. Someone does the math publicly

  8. -78% Nasdaq drawdown

We're between steps 6 and 7.

The Nasdaq peaked March 10, 2000. Recession began March 2001. Markets fell 78% peak-to-trough by October 2002. Companies like Cisco, worth $500 billion at peak, fell 89%. Thousands of companies went to zero.

Today's AI mania already shows cracks. Insiders at tech companies sold $4.2 billion in stock last week—highest since 2021's peak. The "Revenue Reality Ratio" of AI infrastructure spending to AI revenue stands at 31x. The 1999 internet bubble peaked at 28x.

The Framework

Four indicators determine when this fantasy ends:

The Fed Trap Indicator Track the spread between Fed Funds Rate and unemployment rate. Currently: 4.25% Fed Funds minus 4.3% unemployment = -0.05% spread. When this goes negative (unemployment exceeds Fed rate), the Fed loses control. They can't raise rates to fight inflation without crushing employment. They can't cut to save jobs without enabling more speculation. We're already there.

The Liquidation Cascade Signal When defense stocks gain 40%+ while VIX stays below 20, sophisticated money is hedging while retail remains complacent. Current: Defense ETFs up 42-62%, VIX at 16.65. This divergence preceded every major dislocation—Pearl Harbor, Korean War, 2008 crisis. Smart money doesn't wait for CNN to announce problems.

The Breadth Breakdown Metric Percentage of stocks above their 200-day moving average versus index levels. When indices hit records while breadth narrows below 50%, the rally depends on fewer stocks—increasing fragility. Current breadth: deteriorating rapidly. Watch for break below 40%. Below that, only algorithms and the biggest stocks hold up indexes.

The Credit Reality Check High-yield spreads below 3% while consumer delinquencies rise = fatal disconnect. We're at 2.8% spreads despite auto loans at Great Recession highs. When spreads blow out to 5%, it's too late. The move from 3% to 5% happens in days, not months.

Action Thresholds:

When 2 indicators flash (NOW): Raise cash to 20-25%. Reduce to market-weight in growth stocks. Buy 6-month put spreads on QQQ (not investment advice—framework for thinking).

When 3 indicators flash: Cash to 40%. Long volatility through VIX calls. Position in Treasury bonds (TLT).

When 4 indicators flash: Full defensive. It's too late for hedges—they're too expensive. Focus on capital preservation.

Timeline: The February 5, 2018 "Volmageddon" and March 2020 crash both demonstrated modern markets reprice in hours, not weeks. When algorithms detect the shift, cascading liquidation can drop markets 10% in minutes. Circuit breakers provide pauses, not protection.

The Tell: When mainstream financial media explains why "this time is different" regarding AI productivity, you have 3-6 months maximum. When retail investors explain to you why CAPE 40 is justified, you have weeks. When the Fed claims the economy is "strong" while cutting rates with markets at records, the countdown has begun.

Remember: Markets can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent. But they can't stay irrational forever. When 32,000 lost jobs sends markets to record highs, we're not in price discovery—we're in the Fed Put Casino. And the house always wins eventually.

Sources: ADP National Employment Report, Conference Board LEI, CME FedWatch, Federal Reserve Economic Data, Company Filings, Bureau of Labor Statistics (pre-shutdown), FINRA Margin Statistics

Till next time,

Los

Reply

or to participate

More From Capital

No posts found